Wednesday 15 August 2012

Vishnu vs Yahweh


Most Christians provide arguments for the existence of God. I won’t say that those arguments are weak, but what’s weak is that their argument that the universal God is the god of the Old Testament- Yahweh. If God exists, why should it be Yahweh? It could be the Hindu God Vishnu. Why? It’s because Yahweh doesn’t fit the description of “loving, kind and compassionate”. Vishnu does.

Let’s make a comparison between the Hindu God and the Christian God.

Burnt offerings

Yahweh took delight in burnt offerings of innocent animals. (Genesis 4: 4, Leviticus 1: 10- 13) He even approved human sacrifice several times. According to the Old Testament, he won’t allow anyone’s sins to be forgiven without blood being shed. Even though there are several passages in the Old Testament that Yahweh hates animal sacrifices, orthodox Christians pay more attention to the chapters of Exodus and Leviticus. 

However, Lord Vishnu doesn’t accept blood offerings. The Bhagavad Gita makes it clear that the Hindu God prefers people to be righteous and give up worldly attachments. He prefers self-sacrifice, and has no desire for the blood of innocent animals. Plus, in all of His incarnations, Lord Vishnu followed a vegetarian diet. 

So, you decide- who is more merciful- a god who takes pleasure in blood offerings and burnt sacrifices or a god who prefers righteousness?

Murdering innocents

There are lots of examples where the Christian God has murdered innocents.

Deuteronomy 17: 12 specifically say that anyone who doesn’t obey a priest should be killed. It doesn’t matter if the priest did something wrong. 

Leviticus 20: 9 says that anyone who curses his/her parents should be put to death. It doesn’t list any exceptions. So, if a little girl curses her dad because he used to molest her every day, it is the girl you will have to stone, not the father. 

Deuteronomy 13: 12- 15 says that if some people in a town are worshipping other gods, the town should be destroyed and everyone should be killed. Everyone means everyone- even the babies, the children and the animals. Along with the people who committed a minor sin, even the innocents had to die. 

1 Samuel 6: 19 show Yahweh killing a large number of people just for their curiosity. 

There are many more examples where the Christian God has murdered people for stupid reasons. But, the Hindu God never killed any innocent human being or animal. Vishnu even did his best to bring sinners to the right path. He only killed when it was a necessity. And, there isn’t a single story in Hindu mythology where He approved a mass murder among people.

So, you decide who is more merciful- a god who wants innocents killed for stupid reasons, who has no problem with genocides, a god who punishes you with death for almost any kind of sin or a god who is full or forgiveness and mercy, a god who never approves genocides and a god who will not kill any sinner unless he/she crosses the limit?

The theory of punishment

According to orthodox Christianity, if you believe in Jesus Christ and follow his teachings, you will go to heaven for eternity. But, if you don’t believe in him or don’t follow his teachings, you are going to hell for eternity. This theory is stupid, but anyway, that’s not my point here. My point here is that no matter what the crime is, will a merciful god let you burn in hell for eternity? What’s worse is that people are only given one chance- one life. You will be judged based on your actions only on this life and you get no other chance. But according to Hinduism, if you commit sins in this life, you will be born again. And, this cycle of reincarnation will continue till you can become close to perfect and unite with God.
So, you decide who is more merciful- a god who will let those who disobey him burn in hell for eternity or a god who will give you many opportunities to reform yourself?

Many more comparisons can be made between Yahweh and Vishnu, but I don’t want to embarrass the orthodox Christians anymore.

So, what have you decided? If you are to believe in God, whom would you prefer Him to be? Vishnu or Yahweh? 

Blessed are the merciful.